This Collection: | Timeline | Search/Browse | Contributors | Permissions | Help | HOME

Cholera Epidemics in the 19th Century

The Great Plague of London, 1665

The Boston Smallpox Epidemic, 1721

“Pestilence” and the Printed Books of the Late 15th Century

Spanish Influenza in North America, 1918–1919

Syphilis, 1494–1923

Tropical Diseases and the Construction of the Panama Canal, 1904–1914

Tuberculosis in Europe and North America, 1800–1922

The Yellow Fever Epidemic in Philadelphia, 1793

General Materials

Notable People

Related Links

 


Max von Pettenkofer, 1818–1901

Max von Pettenkofer is known as the founder of the discipline of hygiene in Germany. He was well known and highly influential for most of his professional life, much of which was concurrent with the great 19th–century cholera epidemics in Europe. After the mid–1880s, his views on the contagiousness of cholera brought him discredit in the eyes of the international bacteriology community. Pettenkofer believed that cholera was only contagious under certain circumstances. He insisted that the cholera germ, identified by Robert Koch in 1884, required a very specific environment to cause epidemic disease.

Factors X, Y, and Z

Pettenkofer proposed that in order for a cholera epidemic to occur, three factors, which he called X, Y, and Z, were necessary. “X” was the specific pathogen, typically found in the soil. “Y” was the local and seasonal preconditions that allowed the pathogen to transform into a contagious miasma. And “Z” was individual susceptibility to the disease. (When Robert Koch discovered the cholera bacterium in 1884, Pettenkofer said that this germ was the “X” in his theory.) The composition of the soil and its interaction with groundwater was especially important to Pettenkofer’s theory, which is sometimes known as “contingent contagionism” or “localism.”

It was Pettenkofer’s central belief that the cholera germ had to transform or “ferment” under these favorable circumstances before it could become contagious and cause an epidemic. Isolated from these circumstances, the cholera germ could not, in his view, cause disease. Pettenkofer famously demonstrated the strength of this belief in 1892 by drinking a quantity of water infected by pure cultures of the cholera bacillus. Though he did end up getting somewhat ill, he did not develop a full-blown case of cholera.

Quarantine, Contagion, and Hygiene

Pettenkofer’s argument was part of a larger discussion among scientific and medical elites in Europe about contagious disease—in particular, the contagiousness of cholera as epidemics moved from one location to another. The International Sanitary Conferences were convened in part to discuss this issue.

Cholera is a waterborne illness that does not typically spread from person to person by direct contact. A doctor, for example, can treat many cholera patients and never get sick. Anticontagionists typically believed that quarantines were useless against cholera and disrupted trade more than they prevented disease. The British, who controlled trade in many markets, were emphatic in this regard, and went so far as to craft an “official” response refuting Koch’s bacterial theory of cholera transmission, which was published in the Quarterly Journal of Microscopic Science in 1886.

A Localist Approach

Pettenkofer believed that cholera could be imported through the movement of factor X, and that blocking its movement was much more difficult than altering the predisposing factors Y and Z. Quarantines were also too blunt and all–encompassing to fit well into Pettenkofer’s localist approach. Thus, for the most part, Pettenkofer rejected disinfection and quarantine as being impractical. Instead, he advocated for improving local sanitary conditions as the best way to prevent or stop cholera epidemics.

Conflict with Robert Koch

Pettenkofer’s years of greatest influence were the 1860s and the 1870s. He controlled the Cholera Commission for the German Empire until 1884, when Robert Koch’s discovery of the cholera germ fundamentally altered the terms of the discussion.

Koch was an internationally prominent and influential scientist who held a key government position in a German state that was increasingly inclined to interfere with society. Koch denied that the cholera germ underwent any transformation before becoming contagious, and he asserted that the cholera bacillus was spread most easily through water, not soil.

Koch was a strong supporter of quarantine and disinfection, and his advice on how to prevent cholera was completely different from Pettenkofer’s. His recommendation for the strong state intervention that quarantine and disinfection campaigns required fit well with the German government’s priorities, and Pettenkofer’s localized and individualist approach fell out of favor.

^ TOP

Selected Contagion Resources

This is a partial list of digitized materials available in Contagion: Historical Views of Diseases and Epidemics. Additional materials may be found by browsing the topic “Max von Pettenkofer, 1818–1901” and by searching the collection’s Catalog and Full Text databases.

Web Pages

Cholera Epidemics in the 19th Century
Concepts of Contagion and Epidemics
Germ Theory
International Sanitary Conferences
Medical Geography
Public Health, 1800–1922
Robert Koch, 1843–1920

Publications

Anstie, Francis Edmund. Notes on Epidemics: For the Use of the Public. London: Jackson, Walford, and Hodder, 1866.
International Sanitary Conference (4th: 1874: Vienna, Austria). “Procès–Verbaux de la Conférence Sanitaire Internationale Ouverte à Vienne le 1 juillet 1874”. Vienne: Impr. Impériale et Royale, 1874.
Pettenkofer, Max von. Cholera: How to Prevent and Resist It. From the German, translated (with introduction and appendix on the International Cholera–Conference [sic] of Vienna) by Thomas Whiteside Hime; revised by Dr. von Pettenkofer. London: Baillière, Tindall, & Cox, 1883.
Pettenkofer, Max von. Ueber den Gegenwärtigen Stand der Cholera–Frage und Über die Nächsten Aufgaben zur Weiteren Ergründung Ihrer Ursachen. München: R. Oldenbourg, 1873.
Pettenkofer, Max von. Zur Frage Über die Verbreitungsart der Cholera: Entgegnungen und Erläuterungen zu Seiner Schrift “Ueber die Verbreitungsart der Cholera.” München: Cotta, 1855.
Wendt, Edmund Charles. A Treatise on Asiatic Cholera. New York: William Wood and Co., 1885.

References

The following sources were used in writing this page.

Baldwin, Peter. Contagion and the State in Europe, 1830–1930. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005.
Evans, Richard. Death in Hamburg: Society and Politics in the Cholera Years, 1830–1910. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1987.
Jahn, Ellen. Die Cholera in Medizin und Pharmazie im Zeitalter des Hygenikers Max von Pettenkofer. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, 1994.
Ogawa, Mariko. “Uneasy Bedfellows: Science and Politics in the Refutation of Koch’s Bacterial Theory of Cholera.” Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 2000, 74: 671–707.
Porter, Roy. The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1997.
Waller, John. The Discovery of the Germ: Twenty–five Years That Transformed the Way We Think About Disease. New York: Columbia University Press, 2002.

^ TOP

OCP Home | Selection of Web–Accessible Collections | HOLLIS | Harvard Libraries | Harvard Home | Contact | ©2014 The President and Fellows of Harvard College